Willfully Exaggerated Buffalo Mechanic’s Liens: Risks and Damages

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

A mechanic’s lien should state a supportable amount, not an inflated negotiating demand. Contractors working in Buffalo and elsewhere in New York should reconcile the claim before filing and distinguish lienable work from other contract damages.

Calculate the claim from the records

Review the contract, labor and materials, changes, payments, credits and applicable retainage. Do not automatically lien the entire unperformed contract balance or add every claimed delay charge, attorney’s fee or anticipated profit. The Lien Law determines what is lienable; qualifying specially manufactured materials and other statutory rules may require separate analysis.

A disputed change order, accounting error or unsuccessful claim does not automatically prove willful exaggeration. The issue includes whether the overstatement was intentional, not merely whether the lienor ultimately recovered less than the amount claimed.

What Sections 39 and 39-a provide

Under Lien Law § 39, a judicial finding of willful exaggeration can void the entire lien, including its otherwise valid portion. The statute also prohibits another lien for the same claim after that determination.

When the conditions in § 39-a are met in an enforcement action or proceeding, the owner or contractor may recover the amount of the exaggeration, the premium for a discharge bond or interest on discharge funds, and reasonable attorney’s fees for securing the discharge.

For example, if a $50,000 lien is willfully overstated by $30,000, that $30,000 is the exaggeration component of the statutory damages. Section 39-a does not automatically triple it to $90,000. Additional claims or damages require their own legal and factual basis.

For lienors and parties challenging a lien

• Keep a dated calculation connecting the lien to the supporting records.
• Identify genuine disputes and explain changes, credits and payment allocations.
• Respond accurately to any proper itemization demand and court order.
• Obtain advice about correcting an error through an available procedure; do not assume amendment cures every defect.
• Do not assume that alleging exaggeration will produce immediate summary discharge.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC handles lien foreclosure and defense and Section 38 itemization matters. Call 631-752-7100 or email vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.